Use card stock and misc buttons to make your own Christmas cards. The card stock can be bought at Walmart, etc. or at most any craft store. The buttons come in bags at most craft, hobby, or fabric stores.
Simple and effective. Paper plates are a must! Sparkly Paper Plate Angel - for Sunday School I'd let the kids paint glue around edge and then sprinkle clear glitter or silver. Add a ribbon to hang. Write Bible verse on plate?